While the Save jar focuses on the future, the Spend and Give jars focus on the present. These jars teach children how to interact with the world around them—how to make wise choices for themselves and how to show compassion for others. This section explores the difference between "Needs" and "Wants" and the profound psychological impact of charitable giving.
The Spend Jar: A Laboratory for Trial and Error
The Spend jar is where children learn the "value of a dollar" through experience. It is important for parents to allow children to make "small" mistakes with this money. If a child wants to buy a cheap toy that you know will break in ten minutes, let them buy it . When the toy inevitably breaks, it becomes a "valuable lesson in trade-offs" . They will realize that spending their money on low-quality items prevents them from buying higher-quality items later.
Distinguishing Needs vs. Wants
As children enter their elementary years (ages 7-10), the Spend jar provides an opportunity to discuss the difference between "Needs" and "Wants" .
- Needs: Essentials for survival (food, basic clothing, shelter) .
- Wants: Things that make life more enjoyable but aren't necessary (toys, video games, fancy snacks) .
Parents can model this during grocery trips. You might say, "We need milk and bread, but we want these cookies. Since we have a budget, we have to decide if we have enough for the want after the need is covered" . This helps children understand that even adults have to make choices and cannot have everything they see.
The Give Jar: Cultivating Empathy and Purpose
The "Give" jar is often the most overlooked, yet it provides the most significant emotional reward. Giving is how children learn to help those in need . It shifts the focus from "What can I get?" to "What can I contribute?"
How to use the Give Jar:
- Identify a Cause: Talk to your child about what they care about. Do they love animals? Maybe the money goes to a local shelter. Do they want to help other kids? Maybe it goes to a toy drive .
- Make it Tangible: If possible, take the child to deliver the donation in person. Seeing the impact of their "Give" jar—whether it's buying a bag of dog food or dropping coins into a charity bucket—reinforces the idea that their money has the power to do good .
- The "No-Spend" Connection: Sometimes, you can boost the Give jar by doing a "No-Spend Challenge." For one week, the family might agree not to buy any "extras" (like coffee or takeout) and put that saved money into the Give jar instead .
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
Q: Should I pay my child for basic chores like making their bed?
A: Many experts suggest distinguishing between "citizenship chores" (things you do because you are part of the family) and "extra chores" (things you can earn money for, like washing the car or pulling weeds)
. This prevents the child from expecting a payment for every basic task.
Q: What if my child wants to spend their "Save" money on a "Spend" item?
A: This is a "teachable moment." Remind them of their "Eye on the Prize" goal. If they take money out now, it will take much longer to get the big item they really want
. However, allowing them to make the choice (and feel the delay) is often more effective than simply saying "no."
Q: How much should go into the "Give" jar?
A: A common starting point is 10%, but the specific amount matters less than the habit of giving. The goal is to make generosity a standard part of their financial life
.
Q: When should we move from jars to digital apps?
A: Around ages 11-14, children are usually ready for more "tech-savvy" tools
. You might open a youth checking account or use a budgeting app to track their "buckets" digitally
. However, keep the physical jars as long as they are helpful for visual reinforcement.
Summary of the Three-Jar Routine
| Step | Action | Goal |
|---|---|---|
| 1. Earn | Complete a chore or receive a gift | Understand money comes from effort/gifts |
| 2. Divide | Drop coins into Spend, Save, and Give | Practice intentional allocation (bucketing) |
| 3. Visualize | Check the "goal line" on the Save jar | Build patience and delayed gratification |
| 4. Act | Buy a treat, save for a goal, or donate | Experience the three functions of money |
By establishing the Three-Jar System, you are giving your child more than just a place to store coins. You are giving them a framework for making decisions, a sense of agency over their future, and a heart for their community. These simple jars are the building blocks of a healthy, lifelong relationship with cash .
Comments