The bankruptcy system is designed for the "honest but unfortunate" debtor. It is not intended to be a tool for people to commit crimes, hurt others, or intentionally run up bills they never intended to pay . To protect the integrity of the system, the law creates an "Integrity Barrier"—a set of rules that make debts arising from bad behavior non-dischargeable .
Presumptive Fraud: The "Shopping Spree" Rule
One of the most common ways people try to abuse bankruptcy is by loading up their credit cards with luxury purchases or cash advances right before filing, knowing they intend to wipe the debt away . The law calls this presumptive fraud .
The 90-Day and 70-Day Windows
The court looks at your spending in the months leading up to your filing. Two specific triggers can cause a debt to be labeled non-dischargeable:
- Luxury Goods (90 Days): If you owe a single creditor more than a specific dollar amount (currently around $800) for "luxury goods or services" purchased within 90 days of filing, the court presumes you committed fraud .
- Cash Advances (70 Days): If you take cash advances totaling more than a specific amount (currently around $1,100) within 70 days of filing, these are also presumed fraudulent .
What counts as a "Luxury Good"?
Luxury goods are items or services not reasonably necessary for the support or maintenance of the debtor or their dependents
.
- Luxury: Jewelry, high-end electronics, vacations, designer clothing.
- Necessity: Groceries, gasoline, basic clothing, heating oil, medical supplies.
If a creditor objects, you must prove that you intended to pay the debt back or that the items were actually necessities .
Willful and Malicious Injury
Bankruptcy will not protect you from the financial consequences of intentionally hurting someone or their property .
- Willful and Malicious: This means an act was deliberate and done without just cause or excuse .
- Examples: If you intentionally vandalize a neighbor's car, or if you are sued for assault and battery, the resulting court judgment against you cannot be discharged in Chapter 7 .
Note: In Chapter 13, the rules are slightly more lenient regarding property damage, but injuries to people remain non-dischargeable .
DUI and Intoxicated Driving Judgments
Public safety is a major priority in bankruptcy law. If you operate a motor vehicle (including boats or aircraft) while intoxicated by alcohol or drugs and cause personal injury or death to another person, any resulting debt or legal judgment is strictly non-dischargeable . This ensures that those who cause harm through impaired driving remain financially responsible for the damage they've done.
Debts from Crimes: Embezzlement and Larceny
If you stole money or property, you cannot use bankruptcy to keep the "spoils" of your crime. Debts arising from the following are non-dischargeable if the creditor objects:
- Embezzlement: Stealing money that was entrusted to your care (e.g., an employee stealing from a cash register) .
- Larceny: Simple theft .
- Breach of Fiduciary Duty: If you were in a position of trust (like a trustee or corporate officer) and you used that position to commit fraud .
Unscheduled Debts: The "Forgotten" Creditor
When you file for bankruptcy, you are required to list every single person or company you owe money to. This is called "scheduling" your debts .
If you fail to list a creditor on your bankruptcy petition, that debt is unscheduled and may not be discharged . This is because the creditor was never given "due process"—they didn't get a chance to see your filing, attend the meeting of creditors, or object to the discharge .
The Exception: If the creditor found out about your bankruptcy through other means (like a news report or a letter from a friend) and had enough time to file a claim, the debt might still be discharged even if you forgot to list it .
Summary of Conduct-Based Non-Dischargeable Debts
| Behavior | Consequence |
|---|---|
| Buying a Rolex 2 weeks before filing | Presumptive Fraud; debt remains . |
| Taking a $2,000 cash advance to pay rent | May be dischargeable if you can prove it was a necessity . |
| Hitting a pedestrian while drunk driving | Non-dischargeable judgment . |
| Forgetting to list your doctor on the forms | Debt remains (unless they knew about the case) . |
| Intentionally breaking a store's window | Non-dischargeable "willful and malicious" injury . |
How to Protect Your Discharge
To ensure you don't run afoul of these "Integrity Barrier" rules, follow these steps:
- Stop using credit cards: As soon as you realize you need to file for bankruptcy, stop all non-essential spending .
- Be honest and thorough: List every single debt, even if it's money you owe to a family member or a small medical bill .
- Keep your records: Don't throw away receipts, bank statements, or tax returns. The trustee may ask to see them to verify your spending .
- Avoid large transfers: Don't give away your car or sell your house for $1 to a friend before filing; this is considered a fraudulent transfer and can lead to a total denial of your discharge .
By acting in good faith and following the rules, you ensure that the "Debt Filter" works in your favor, catching only the debts you truly cannot pay while allowing you to move forward with a clean financial slate .
Comments